Don wrote:
Abena makes the plastic backed diapers and the air plus diaper. Both diapers sell well according to XPmed. I don't think the Abena is in any danger of going strictly cloth. I can't wear cloth backed diapers. They give me a rash. And they feel wet and cold. I have a great appreciation for plastic backed abena's. The VA buys them for me from XP.
Unfortunately the danger is very real. Gary is doing what he can to at least keep some options (medium and large M4) around but most of the selection in Abena's plastic-backed line is almost certainly going away for good.
http://disposablediaper.net/faq.asp?16I found this article when doing some googling that explains a lot of it.
Basically there is just a "perception" of cloth-backed disposables being more comfortable...and (at least in my experience, and many other people's too) that's not true at all. There's also the fact that a cloth-backed disposable feels a lot less like a diaper to many people. I admit my first inclination was not to try a plastic-backed disposable once I learned there were other possibilities. But the cloth-backed stuff chaffes and urine sweats through the backsheet, it's just...a bad, bad solution for me. And they aren't any cooler. I think I remember reading that they only dissipate about 10% more heat than a normal plastic-backed disposable. Not something I'm willing to trade any degree of watertightness for =/.
There's also the (incorrect) assumption that cloth-backed disposables are more environmentally friendly...which, again, isn't true. "Cloth-backed" is still plastic, it's just woven different to give it a different feel. They're still going to wind up in a landfill (which I have no qualms about but that is a nasty political subject I don't care to touch).
Anyway I suspect they are getting market pressure to "appear" more environmentally friendly, and have less "diaper-like" products on the market.
I still can't imagine this decision doing any good for them. They sell too many plastic-backed diapers for this to be a smart move. Even if they only make up 20% of their sales, on the scale they are selling...that's just very, very stupid.