This is another reply to an older post, made 3/23 by Tom, when he asked IMR why bother with plastic pants if he was wearing his (cloth) diapers outdoors in the yard.
I have experimented with that since I've the luxury of a private backyard with fencing and trees that provide me with total privacy from neighbors. I would think cloth diapers would be much cooler without waterproof pants and further cooling would be realized as wetness evaporated from the surface of the diapers. Well, the theory is all good...but in practice, it comes up short.
The experiments I carried out consisted of cutting the grass, hanging laundry and lounging in the patio furniture.
Cutting the grass seems like the best case for enjoying the expected comfort of no plastic pants. Well, I was wearing a wet diaper (my incon is such that I never know when I am wetting and I wet frequently so I am always in a diaper that is wet to some degree) and I pulled off the plastic pants to cut the grass. Well, the slip value of the plastic pants between the legs was now gone. Walking in a wet diaper was not that comfortable. The rubbing would lead to chaffing of the inner thighs. Next, as I am cutting away, following the lawn mower, comes the tickle of dribbling down my legs. I stop and note the stream of wetness follow down a leg and soak into the sock and sneaker. OK, that was the end of that experiment. It has nothing to recommend it. The "heat" of the plastic pants is a better alternative to the discomfort of peeing down a leg and into the shoes which now have to laundered.
Next, hanging the laundry or retrieving the laundry, ie folding diapers and so on which I do all outdoors with a handy picnic table to work with. For this experiment I ditched the shoes and socks! The clothesline area is paved so no worry about stepping on a sharp stone or a bee and getting stung, as with mowing the lawn. Less strenuous walking so the chaffing factor is much less with the damp cloth between the thighs. But I experienced the same disconcerting dribble down the leg and, of course, a puddle of pee soaking into the ground. Well, you know that will lead to odor problems until the rains come to wash it into the soil. So we have to get the hose and dilute and wash the puddle away. Plastic pants seem so much easier than this, I am saying to myself.
The last experiment, lounging, reading the paper and enjoying a cool beverage sounds ideal for the cloth diaper and no "hot" waterproof pants! In my lounge chair, I don't even feel any tickle or other disconcerting evidence of peeing. But at the end of the lounge, when I have to get up and do something else, I now have a lounge chair and a puddle of pee under it, both of which must be delt with for sanitary reasons and to avoid odor problems. And look at it this way, would you knowingly pee while sitting in your chair on the patio, knowing you have to clean up the chair and the patio? I don't think so. Therefore, plastic pants are an integral part of the diaper. I want to contain the pee (for sanitary and odor reasons) so I can effectively deal with it in the washing machine. I do NOT want to deal with cleaning up patio furniture and puddles around the yard.
So, for me, not wearing plastic pants was the pits. I don't find plastic pants all that "hot" but we all have various degrees of perception and what is comfortable or tolerable. I will strongly suggest that folks try different waterproof pants for comfort in the hot weather. I can tolerate plastic very well but I will recommend nylon pants-especially the DuraTex since they do breath and the clamminess is not uncomfortable in the heat and provides some small measure of evaporative cooling between the legs.
For others who may dislike the damp feel, there is Kins Softees vinyl pants that feel more like silk than plastic. I find them very comfortable even during the swealtering heat we've all been experiencing to some degree. You may think that they are no different from, say, Gary plastic pants, but I really feel they are different and more comfortable to wear if you hate the sweaty feel of vinyl between your legs on a hot day.
On a final note, waterproof pants are more comfortable when you wear nothing over them. Now you can only get away with this in the privacy of your home and perhaps your yard. But the lack of shorts allows the air movement that keeps it cooler on your thighs. Even light boxer shorts have legs that capture that heat to some degree and interfer with air circulation. Sure we have to wear shorts when we go out, but as soon as I get home, the shorts come off and I can tell the difference in comfort level. So for those of you who have never "uncovered", try it if you can. Yes, I know most have spouses but if the two of you are trying to beat the heat, neither of you will be wearing any "excess" clothing, and with you in a diaper and plastic pants, the shorts are clearly in the "excess clothing" category. But that is a domestic issue for the two principals to work out!
Joe K
|